Love the energy with "i decided to just go for it.".
The soldering to the touchpad is absolutely frightful, but you know what? First time soldering (to small testpoints no less), it works, it can always be fixed later if the joints fail. I've been getting too caught up in perfection with my recent projects, it's a good reminder that with a userbase of 1, it really doesn't matter.
They never actually say what the project is, LOL. I figured out that it’s to put the guts of a framework laptop into an old MacBook case.
[deleted]
Well done for figuring it out
I have an old aluminium 17" MacBook. It got retired fairly early because it suffered from a design flaw but was outside the free replacement window.
Its screen is nice, and there looks to be plenty of room inside. I have been keeping an eye on options for putting something else inside. Its mostly the power delivery for the display that I think is beyond my skill that's holding me back.
You may be interested in this Framework build that converted a 17" MBP.
Mine is a random reset when GPU kicks in, Apparently it's a single tiny component that needs to be changed, but to get to it requires almost complete disassembly. The cost of having it done professionally probably more than it's worth. Chance of breaking it by doing it myself too high.
But now I'm just thinking of it as a solid box with nice screen and keyboard attached.
The worst part is that the discrete GPU was used to drive external displays, so now I’m stuck with a 17” integrated display, which is large for a laptop but still small for a computer that I’ll never again lug with me (it’s heavy by today’s standards).
Wow, 64 GB of RAM.
I'm really tempted to build a modern computer into an HP Jornada case. I really miss that form factor. It's pocketable yet has a usable keyboard.
I used to run Linux (JLime Linux) and NetBSD on those. I did prefer the bigger NEC MobilePro competitors though, but I spent so much time on those Jornadas in college.
At some point some kristoff guy was developing some flashrom boards so that jlime linux on the hp jornada could have actual suspend to ram.
On one hand, it would’ve been cool.
On the other hand, at the time netbooks were becoming common and were essentially taking the spot of those kind of devices (jornada 728 etc).
I can only imagine a giant using the domestically-produced hardware of Lilliput.
You mean one of the wider ones? Look a little like cyberdecks.
Is it easy these days to get a mortgage for 64 GB of RAM?
Just buy it on credit and then delete the app.
That's called Affirm
Negative.
> . i learned alot from this project, from how to solder,
This part is simply amazing, the "nothing is impossible" drive!
The palm rest plastic and screen frame cracked on almost all of these. Not a model I romanticize.
I remember these Macbooks did tend to break apart at the corners of the palmrests.
But I like the idea of re-visiting Macbook plastic chassis w/ new inside.
I would love to know what the weight is in the end.
Can the old Macbook chassis lead to a lighter weight computer than the current 1.23kg Macbook neo and Macbook air?
> I remember these Macbooks did tend to break apart at the corners of the palmrests.
Not the corners for me, but the "feet" of the topcase digging into the palmrest, which would splinter the plastic, then you'd have holes in the case and jagged plastic splinters digging into your wrist as you typed, not enjoyable.
Shame because it was the last macbook that was really easy to upgrade: the battery was removable (with a simple lock), and behind it were the RAM and 2.5" drive slots.
The next generation was not that hard but you had to unscrew the entire bottom shell, and the battery was glued.
Unscrewing the bottom on the generations after this gave you access to nearly everything. Which was vastly superior for most repairs. Getting to the logic board or AirPort card on the polycarbonate MacBook took significantly longer. For the Bluetooth motherboard you had to remove the display cable, optical drive and HDD.
That’s what happened to my 2006 Core Duo MacBook after about three or four years of use. It was an excellent laptop that was quite user-serviceable (I upgraded the RAM and hard drive), but I did have problems with the palmrests, and the Ethernet port stopped working after four years.
It was my first Apple laptop and I have fond memories of using it during my college years.
I had one of those machines in university too and had the same stained/cracked palmrests. That said, I also paid for extended AppleCare and had the whole top case swapped for free multiple times throughout the three years that the coverage lasted.
When I was a broke student I would buy MacBooks with broken palm rests for a discounted price, drop them off at Apple for a free repair (under extended warranty) and flip them for a profit. Three hours of my time turned into €100 profit. Minimum wage was €6/hour back then.
Did the same years later buying up first gen iPod Nano and trading them in for sixth gen because of the battery recall.
The plastic by the trackpad would turn pink as well from my sweaty hands. Good times.
From all those long sessions playing Call of Duty and Quake 4!
I’d love the same thing but with the titanium powerbooks / intels. What a beautiful design it was.
I liked my old magnesium Thinkpad T41p but it was a different aesthetic.
I want a laptop form factor that is basically a briefcase with the display, computer and battery with space for a keyboard and mouse of some kind. I basically hate laptop keyboards/trackpads but want a portable computer. Plan on building my own at some point using frame.work components as the base but I haven't started on it yet. One day.
I want something like the huawei matebook fold but with a stand to raise the screen to an ergonomic height.
could this not be solved by just getting a laptop and also carrying external kb and mouse?
I'd like it in a setup that makes usable as a portable without a lot of setup. IMO it is feasibly to disable the keyboard/trackpad and just put my keyboard on top but it isn't ideal.
That is pretty cool, I would not have the time, creativity and dedication to start something like that. Wanted to donate a nice comment. Best regards
very cool project. id like to do something similar with my favorite thinkpad models.
that said, practice soldering, the insulation on those wires[0] and the sheer distance that they wicked solder upwards makes me really wonder how much heat got dumped into those tiny pads!
Agreed, this got me thinking maybe I should try something similar with my own old macbook pro. They did mention that this was the first time they had soldered anything, so it's great that they went for it and it worked! So now it's just a matter of improving technique.
Long term, that may need to be redone. Really want less exposed wire in the final product, tin the tips of the wire first so they don't suck up the solder and trim to the appropriate length(only a bit bigger than the size of the pads at most). This is a good example on tinning: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pRPF4wpXX9Q And if you need to expose a lot of wire then just use some heatshrink so it's not exposed once you're done.
In a perfect world, you'd want to remove all the existing solder and then re-solder everything. But de-soldering can be its own skill and isn't always strictly necessary. Just something more to work toward.
I had a black and white MacBook that was a Frankensteins Monster made out of at least 3 of these. It was around 2011-12 and I couldn’t afford anything else. I think I still remember how to disassemble them by heart… <3
This is pretty impressive! I'm always impressed with what one can 3D print to fit commercial products into a previous case! Modifying to fit the larger webcam module, battery in that way was neat too. Does the display connect via framework's cable without modification? I have an old motherboard running headless I was thinking of resurrecting but if I need to hook up a USC-C display.
An ebook reader from Framework would be awesome....
I would imagine battery life would be poor vs an eReader. In case you seek the same: I used a boox onyx (12"?) and OK overall. Issues IMO were the display is very fragile & did it in in the end despite a case and pocket in the bag, color was a bit of gimmick, most importantly the resolution was not good enough read journals/PDFs/stuff like the guardian weekly via libby crisply without zooming in... but the rest was decent. I switched to a kindle scribe I got for 1/3 the price after but it can't read the guardian or anything like that unfortunately like an android tablet. So just a bulky eReader with meeting notes there. If it even just showed my daily calendar I’d be happy.
Boox Note Air 5C is €530, Kindle Scribe also in the region. Pine does tend to have a bit of a premium spec for spec, presumably largely from (lack of) scale.
Or a printer...
Or a phone ...
Or a router ...
No one will make a printer because the margins are so low. They are like the FMCG [0] of the tech world
Now you should go and reinforce the two lines on top of the screen, make them wider. Or replace them with something softer. Otherwise they will crush your topcase to a pulp. Like they did on every genuine macbook out there for many years because Apple never bothered to fix it.
Personally I thought the later plastic macbook with the rounded edges was a much nicer design. Or the earliest white iBooks, which had a transparent case with white paint inside so they had this really cool glow. Unfortunately that caused shadows on the tiniest scratch which acted like a magnifying glass, so you really had to keep it pristine. But in those days a macbook was super expensive so I always kept mine in sleeves.
By the way I love what you've done with the EL film powering the back apple light. That looks amazing. It should always have been implemented like this, so you can drive it separately.
Interesting because I always felt like the Framework already looks like a Macbook Pro with the grey case and the black keys.
This is brilliant! The techniques remind me of a lot of my Toughbook modding, back in the day, which I did not document nearly enough.
I still have the shell of a CF-17 that's just begging for new guts... but I'd have to aim for something quite a bit lower-power as it's a sealed chassis with no provision for air cooling. Perhaps a CM4-based build...
Aaah! Why must other people be so productive! It gives me too many projects!
So it's a Hackintosh?
Idk what the word for it is
Hackintosh typically refers to running not-MacOS on apple hardware? Imo this project of removing almost all of the inner guts and using effectively a Frankenstein'd collection of things to reconstitute it into laptop needs a different word.
If it were me I would choose
Franekntosh
No, Hackintosh specifically refers to running MacOS on non-Apple hardware.
I don't think there's a word for running other OSs on Apple hardware, because it's officially supported.
[deleted]
[dead]
Looks like Windows with a very MacOS-esque theme rather than a proper hackintosh, the screenshot says Windows 11 IoT Enterprise.
I previously had a pretty good experience with it before moving to Linux.
Scrolled down just to find this comment
I was initially so happy to see a Linux build that looked so much like macOS, but then saw windows 11 pro on the about, and died inside..
I guess that’s why it has 64 gb of ram, so that there’s 10 left for applications after windows is done lol
Indeed, is not a Mac, I really expected some old MACOS
Hackintosh refers to doing things the other way around: running MacOS on non-apple hardware. So no, this is not a hackintosh.
In a way, it’s the exact opposite
Can I just say again that I absolutely love what Framework's built/enabled? Between projects like this and things like the RISC dev board, they've immediately become the hacker supplier of choice. When they first debuted, I was skeptical they'd survive, but they've really shown you can build a successful company for a niche audience, and they've had a huge impact for the maker community.
I wish the same could be done with the 11 inch MacBook airs, still my favorite laptop I’ve owned.
I still rock one of these running Linux and it’s plenty capable for my hobby workloads. Just had to replace the inflating battery!
What era and which distro? I have one from ~ 2011... would be cool to do something with it.
Dog ate your shift key?
The first-gen macbook shared a lot of internals with certain Dell laptops of the era. In 2010 I was homeless and attending high school at a boarding school and didn't have nice macbooks like my classmates, but I cobbled together my first laptop that summer from a few different old salvaged Dell models.
Dual-booting into a hackintosh was a breeze. I eventually salvaged an old T60 and it was a similar case, enough crossover in components that it wasn't any trouble running macOS.
This was in an era where you wanted Apple software even on non-Apple hardware. Today, it's the opposite.
The mid-2000s Yahoo chat writing style is too grating for me in this article.
Noice!
theseus's macbook, love it!
Very cool!
[deleted]
[dead]
Young people.
[deleted]
[flagged]
[flagged]
[flagged]
Ugh, those bezels are so 2000. Maybe a good laptop if you don't wanna look at it all the time (e.g., as a home server).
Love the energy with "i decided to just go for it.". The soldering to the touchpad is absolutely frightful, but you know what? First time soldering (to small testpoints no less), it works, it can always be fixed later if the joints fail. I've been getting too caught up in perfection with my recent projects, it's a good reminder that with a userbase of 1, it really doesn't matter.
They never actually say what the project is, LOL. I figured out that it’s to put the guts of a framework laptop into an old MacBook case.
Well done for figuring it out
I have an old aluminium 17" MacBook. It got retired fairly early because it suffered from a design flaw but was outside the free replacement window.
Its screen is nice, and there looks to be plenty of room inside. I have been keeping an eye on options for putting something else inside. Its mostly the power delivery for the display that I think is beyond my skill that's holding me back.
You may be interested in this Framework build that converted a 17" MBP.
https://community.frame.work/t/i-converted-a-macbook-into-a-...
Melted GPU? I’m still sore about that one.
Mine is a random reset when GPU kicks in, Apparently it's a single tiny component that needs to be changed, but to get to it requires almost complete disassembly. The cost of having it done professionally probably more than it's worth. Chance of breaking it by doing it myself too high.
But now I'm just thinking of it as a solid box with nice screen and keyboard attached.
The worst part is that the discrete GPU was used to drive external displays, so now I’m stuck with a 17” integrated display, which is large for a laptop but still small for a computer that I’ll never again lug with me (it’s heavy by today’s standards).
Wow, 64 GB of RAM.
I'm really tempted to build a modern computer into an HP Jornada case. I really miss that form factor. It's pocketable yet has a usable keyboard.
I used to run Linux (JLime Linux) and NetBSD on those. I did prefer the bigger NEC MobilePro competitors though, but I spent so much time on those Jornadas in college.
At some point some kristoff guy was developing some flashrom boards so that jlime linux on the hp jornada could have actual suspend to ram.
On one hand, it would’ve been cool.
On the other hand, at the time netbooks were becoming common and were essentially taking the spot of those kind of devices (jornada 728 etc).
I can only imagine a giant using the domestically-produced hardware of Lilliput.
You mean one of the wider ones? Look a little like cyberdecks.
Is it easy these days to get a mortgage for 64 GB of RAM?
Just buy it on credit and then delete the app.
That's called Affirm
Negative.
> . i learned alot from this project, from how to solder,
This part is simply amazing, the "nothing is impossible" drive!
The palm rest plastic and screen frame cracked on almost all of these. Not a model I romanticize.
https://www.cultofmac.com/how-to/exchange-your-cracked-macbo...
I remember these Macbooks did tend to break apart at the corners of the palmrests.
But I like the idea of re-visiting Macbook plastic chassis w/ new inside.
I would love to know what the weight is in the end.
Can the old Macbook chassis lead to a lighter weight computer than the current 1.23kg Macbook neo and Macbook air?
> I remember these Macbooks did tend to break apart at the corners of the palmrests.
Not the corners for me, but the "feet" of the topcase digging into the palmrest, which would splinter the plastic, then you'd have holes in the case and jagged plastic splinters digging into your wrist as you typed, not enjoyable.
This: https://ismh.s3.amazonaws.com/2014-02-24-macbook-topcase.jpg is exactly what mine had, on both sides.
Shame because it was the last macbook that was really easy to upgrade: the battery was removable (with a simple lock), and behind it were the RAM and 2.5" drive slots.
The next generation was not that hard but you had to unscrew the entire bottom shell, and the battery was glued.
Unscrewing the bottom on the generations after this gave you access to nearly everything. Which was vastly superior for most repairs. Getting to the logic board or AirPort card on the polycarbonate MacBook took significantly longer. For the Bluetooth motherboard you had to remove the display cable, optical drive and HDD.
That’s what happened to my 2006 Core Duo MacBook after about three or four years of use. It was an excellent laptop that was quite user-serviceable (I upgraded the RAM and hard drive), but I did have problems with the palmrests, and the Ethernet port stopped working after four years.
It was my first Apple laptop and I have fond memories of using it during my college years.
I had one of those machines in university too and had the same stained/cracked palmrests. That said, I also paid for extended AppleCare and had the whole top case swapped for free multiple times throughout the three years that the coverage lasted.
When I was a broke student I would buy MacBooks with broken palm rests for a discounted price, drop them off at Apple for a free repair (under extended warranty) and flip them for a profit. Three hours of my time turned into €100 profit. Minimum wage was €6/hour back then.
Did the same years later buying up first gen iPod Nano and trading them in for sixth gen because of the battery recall.
The plastic by the trackpad would turn pink as well from my sweaty hands. Good times.
From all those long sessions playing Call of Duty and Quake 4!
I’d love the same thing but with the titanium powerbooks / intels. What a beautiful design it was.
I liked my old magnesium Thinkpad T41p but it was a different aesthetic.
I want a laptop form factor that is basically a briefcase with the display, computer and battery with space for a keyboard and mouse of some kind. I basically hate laptop keyboards/trackpads but want a portable computer. Plan on building my own at some point using frame.work components as the base but I haven't started on it yet. One day.
I want something like the huawei matebook fold but with a stand to raise the screen to an ergonomic height.
could this not be solved by just getting a laptop and also carrying external kb and mouse?
I'd like it in a setup that makes usable as a portable without a lot of setup. IMO it is feasibly to disable the keyboard/trackpad and just put my keyboard on top but it isn't ideal.
That is pretty cool, I would not have the time, creativity and dedication to start something like that. Wanted to donate a nice comment. Best regards
very cool project. id like to do something similar with my favorite thinkpad models.
that said, practice soldering, the insulation on those wires[0] and the sheer distance that they wicked solder upwards makes me really wonder how much heat got dumped into those tiny pads!
[0]: https://fb.edoo.gg/assets/images/image06.jpg?v=86ae0ddf
Agreed, this got me thinking maybe I should try something similar with my own old macbook pro. They did mention that this was the first time they had soldered anything, so it's great that they went for it and it worked! So now it's just a matter of improving technique.
Long term, that may need to be redone. Really want less exposed wire in the final product, tin the tips of the wire first so they don't suck up the solder and trim to the appropriate length(only a bit bigger than the size of the pads at most). This is a good example on tinning: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pRPF4wpXX9Q And if you need to expose a lot of wire then just use some heatshrink so it's not exposed once you're done.
In a perfect world, you'd want to remove all the existing solder and then re-solder everything. But de-soldering can be its own skill and isn't always strictly necessary. Just something more to work toward.
for cool framework thinkpad project, see https://github.com/Maglev-Rabbit/702_Project_Public.
I had a black and white MacBook that was a Frankensteins Monster made out of at least 3 of these. It was around 2011-12 and I couldn’t afford anything else. I think I still remember how to disassemble them by heart… <3
This is pretty impressive! I'm always impressed with what one can 3D print to fit commercial products into a previous case! Modifying to fit the larger webcam module, battery in that way was neat too. Does the display connect via framework's cable without modification? I have an old motherboard running headless I was thinking of resurrecting but if I need to hook up a USC-C display.
An ebook reader from Framework would be awesome....
I would imagine battery life would be poor vs an eReader. In case you seek the same: I used a boox onyx (12"?) and OK overall. Issues IMO were the display is very fragile & did it in in the end despite a case and pocket in the bag, color was a bit of gimmick, most importantly the resolution was not good enough read journals/PDFs/stuff like the guardian weekly via libby crisply without zooming in... but the rest was decent. I switched to a kindle scribe I got for 1/3 the price after but it can't read the guardian or anything like that unfortunately like an android tablet. So just a bulky eReader with meeting notes there. If it even just showed my daily calendar I’d be happy.
This is probably close enough:
https://pine64.org/devices/pinenote/
610 Euros seems quite steep for an eReader.
Boox Note Air 5C is €530, Kindle Scribe also in the region. Pine does tend to have a bit of a premium spec for spec, presumably largely from (lack of) scale.
Or a printer...
Or a phone ...
Or a router ...
No one will make a printer because the margins are so low. They are like the FMCG [0] of the tech world
0, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fast-moving_consumer_goods
* OpenPrinter has entered the chat.
https://www.opentools.studio/
Phone is thankfully covered by Fairphone.
Now you should go and reinforce the two lines on top of the screen, make them wider. Or replace them with something softer. Otherwise they will crush your topcase to a pulp. Like they did on every genuine macbook out there for many years because Apple never bothered to fix it.
Personally I thought the later plastic macbook with the rounded edges was a much nicer design. Or the earliest white iBooks, which had a transparent case with white paint inside so they had this really cool glow. Unfortunately that caused shadows on the tiniest scratch which acted like a magnifying glass, so you really had to keep it pristine. But in those days a macbook was super expensive so I always kept mine in sleeves.
By the way I love what you've done with the EL film powering the back apple light. That looks amazing. It should always have been implemented like this, so you can drive it separately.
Interesting because I always felt like the Framework already looks like a Macbook Pro with the grey case and the black keys.
This is brilliant! The techniques remind me of a lot of my Toughbook modding, back in the day, which I did not document nearly enough.
I still have the shell of a CF-17 that's just begging for new guts... but I'd have to aim for something quite a bit lower-power as it's a sealed chassis with no provision for air cooling. Perhaps a CM4-based build...
Aaah! Why must other people be so productive! It gives me too many projects!
So it's a Hackintosh?
Idk what the word for it is
Hackintosh typically refers to running not-MacOS on apple hardware? Imo this project of removing almost all of the inner guts and using effectively a Frankenstein'd collection of things to reconstitute it into laptop needs a different word.
If it were me I would choose
Franekntosh
No, Hackintosh specifically refers to running MacOS on non-Apple hardware.
I don't think there's a word for running other OSs on Apple hardware, because it's officially supported.
[dead]
Looks like Windows with a very MacOS-esque theme rather than a proper hackintosh, the screenshot says Windows 11 IoT Enterprise.
For people curious, it looks like it is MyDockFinder. https://store.steampowered.com/app/1787090/MyDockFinder/
I previously had a pretty good experience with it before moving to Linux.
Scrolled down just to find this comment
I was initially so happy to see a Linux build that looked so much like macOS, but then saw windows 11 pro on the about, and died inside..
I guess that’s why it has 64 gb of ram, so that there’s 10 left for applications after windows is done lol
Indeed, is not a Mac, I really expected some old MACOS
Hackintosh refers to doing things the other way around: running MacOS on non-apple hardware. So no, this is not a hackintosh.
In a way, it’s the exact opposite
Can I just say again that I absolutely love what Framework's built/enabled? Between projects like this and things like the RISC dev board, they've immediately become the hacker supplier of choice. When they first debuted, I was skeptical they'd survive, but they've really shown you can build a successful company for a niche audience, and they've had a huge impact for the maker community.
I wish the same could be done with the 11 inch MacBook airs, still my favorite laptop I’ve owned.
I still rock one of these running Linux and it’s plenty capable for my hobby workloads. Just had to replace the inflating battery!
What era and which distro? I have one from ~ 2011... would be cool to do something with it.
Dog ate your shift key?
The first-gen macbook shared a lot of internals with certain Dell laptops of the era. In 2010 I was homeless and attending high school at a boarding school and didn't have nice macbooks like my classmates, but I cobbled together my first laptop that summer from a few different old salvaged Dell models.
Dual-booting into a hackintosh was a breeze. I eventually salvaged an old T60 and it was a similar case, enough crossover in components that it wasn't any trouble running macOS.
This was in an era where you wanted Apple software even on non-Apple hardware. Today, it's the opposite.
The mid-2000s Yahoo chat writing style is too grating for me in this article.
Noice!
theseus's macbook, love it!
Very cool!
[dead]
Young people.
[flagged]
[flagged]
[flagged]
Ugh, those bezels are so 2000. Maybe a good laptop if you don't wanna look at it all the time (e.g., as a home server).